Good Cause Eviction: what Brooklyn owners need to know
Which buildings are covered, what counts as a reasonable increase, and how it changes the way you set a renewal.
Good Cause Eviction has been law in New York City since April 2024. If you own a small building in Brooklyn, it probably changes how you handle renewals, and it definitely changes what you should put in writing.
Is your building covered?
Most market-rate apartments in the city are covered unless an exemption applies. The big ones: you own ten or fewer units total across all your properties and live in one of them (small landlord exemption); the unit is in a building of ten or fewer units where you personally occupy one; the building got its certificate of occupancy after 2009; or the rent is above the high-rent threshold (245 percent of fair market rent, which for a Brooklyn one-bedroom is roughly $6,000 and up). Rent-stabilized units already have their own rules and are not affected.
What "good cause" means in practice
If a tenant is covered, you can only decline to renew or move to evict for a listed reason: nonpayment, lease violations, nuisance, illegal use, refusing reasonable access, the owner or family moving in, or taking the unit off the market. "I'd rather have a new tenant at a higher rent" is not on the list.
The renewal increase rule
An increase above the local threshold is presumed unreasonable and a tenant can raise it as a defense. The threshold is the lower of 10 percent or CPI plus 5 percent, recalculated each year; for 2026 it sits just under 9 percent. You can go higher if you can show why (a documented capital improvement, a real jump in taxes or insurance), but the burden is yours.
What to do before your next renewal
Every lease and renewal for a covered unit now needs the state's Good Cause notice attached, and every non-renewal or increase above threshold needs a written explanation. We handle the notices on the buildings we lease. If you self-manage, get the form from the state, and if you're unsure whether you're exempt, ask before you send a number, not after.
Sources
- NYS Homes and Community Renewal: Good Cause Eviction
- NYS HCR: required Good Cause Eviction notice (May 2026)
- NYC HPD: Good Cause Eviction
Checked May 2026. Laws and guidelines change; the official pages above are always current.
COPA passed: what it means if you're selling a building in New York City
The City Council voted to give qualified nonprofits the first chance to buy certain apartment buildings. Which buildings are covered, how the 20 and 70 day clock works, and what owners should do now.
October 2026 · 5 minRentingThe rent freeze is here: what it means if you're rent-stabilized
Starting October 1, renewals on rent-stabilized apartments carry a 0% increase for one- and two-year leases. Who it covers, who it doesn't, and what to check on your renewal.
October 2026 · 4 min